To trade or not to trade? Breaking the ivory deadlock


Share post:

The debate over whether legal trading of ivory should be allowed to fund elephant conservation, or banned altogether to stop poaching has raged for decades without an end in sight.

To trade or not to trade? Breaking the ivory deadlock
Scientists propose a process to protect endangered African elephants that take into account conflicts over values 
[Credit: Oxford University]

Now, an international team including researchers from The University of Queensland and the ARC Centre of Excellence for Environmental Decisions (CEED) is working to break the policy stalemate.

UQ CEED postdoctoral researcher Dr Matthew Holden said the team identified a process aimed to overcome the deadlock on ivory.

“We believe there hasn’t been a resolution because each side of the debate has failed to recognise the other’s moral perspectives,” Dr Holden said.

“People are more likely to unconsciously challenge information coming from someone with a different moral view, like we see with climate change,” he said.

“Drawing on what we’ve learned from other polarised debates, we developed a structured process aimed to help stakeholders better understand each other’s perspective, and make informed policy decisions.”

The researchers recognise the politics around ivory policy are challenging, but urge countries and organisations committed to elephant conservation to initiate such a process.

Lead author Dr Duan Biggs, who began the research as a UQ CEED postdoc researcher, said the policy impasse was wasting valuable conservation resources.

“Scientific information alone will not solve contentious issues like ivory trade,” Dr Biggs said.

“Identifying people’s beliefs, values and perspectives on ivory trade can help overcome the deadlock on ivory policy.”

The researchers say the continued policy deadlock on the trade of products from iconic species like elephant and rhino is harming the conservation of these animals.

The research is published in Science.

Source: University of Queensland [December 15, 2017]



Related articles

East Antarctica’s Denman Glacier has retreated almost 3 miles over last 22 years

East Antarctica's Denman Glacier has retreated 5 kilometers, nearly 3 miles, in the past 22 years, and researchers...

Reconstruction of prehistoric temperatures for some of the oldest archaeological sites in North America

Scientists often look to the past for clues about how Earth’s landscapes might shift under a changing climate,...

Observations confirm model predictions of sea-level change from Greenland melt

Rising sea levels from melting glaciers and ice sheets pose an increasing threat to coastal communities worldwide. A...

Study shows one third of world’s protected areas degraded by human activities

A shocking study in the journal Science by the University of Queensland, Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), and University...

Study presents new clues about the rise of Earth’s continents

Continents are part of what makes Earth uniquely habitable for life among the planets of the solar system,...

NASA provides detailed pictures of ice loss following collapse of Antarctic Ice Shelves

An international team of researchers has combined data from multiple sources to provide the clearest account yet of...

Earth’s orbit affects millennial climate variability

Abundant geological evidence demonstrates that Earth's climate has experienced millennial-scale variability superimposed on glacial-interglacial fluctuations through the Pleistocene....

New model shows southern and central Rocky Mountains were formed differently than originally thought

A new model built in part by a University of Alberta geophysicist contradicts a long-held idea about how...