Research ‘final nail in the coffin’ of Paranthropus as hard object feeders


Share post:

New research from the University of Otago debunks a long-held belief about our ancestors’ eating habits.

Research 'final nail in the coffin' of Paranthropus as hard object feeders
Paranthropus boisei [Credit: © Roman Yevseyev]

For more than 60 years, researchers have believed Paranthropus, a close fossil relative of ours which lived about one to three million years ago, evolved massive back teeth to consume hard food items such as seeds and nuts, while our own direct ancestors, the genus Homo, is thought to have evolved smaller teeth due to eating softer food such as cooked food and meats.

However, after travelling to several large institutes and museums in South Africa, Japan and the United Kingdom and studying tooth fractures in more than 20,000 teeth of fossil and living primate species, Dr Ian Towle, an Otago biological anthropologist, working with Dr Carolina Loch, of the Faculty of Dentistry, says this “neat picture is far more complex than once thought”.

“By individually studying each tooth and recording the position and size of any tooth fractures, we show tooth chipping does not support regular hard food eating in Paranthropus robustus, therefore potentially putting an end to the argument that this group as a whole were hard food eaters,” he says.

Dr Towle says the findings challenge our understanding of dietary and behavioural changes during human evolution.

“The results are surprising, with human fossils so far studied – those in our own genus Homo – showing extremely high rates of tooth fractures, similar to living hard object eating primates, yet Paranthropus show extremely low levels of fracture, similar to primates that eat soft fruits or leaves.

“Although in recent years there has been a slow acceptance that another species of Paranthropus, Paranthropus boisei, found in East Africa, was unlikely to have regularly eaten hard foods, the notion that Paranthropus evolved their large dental apparatus to eat hard foods has persisted. Therefore, this research can be seen as the final nail in the coffin of Paranthropus as hard object feeders.”

Research 'final nail in the coffin' of Paranthropus as hard object feeders
The jaw of Paranthropus robustus shows large molars [Credit: Ian Towle et al. 2021]

The fact that humans show such contrasting chipping patterns is equally significant and will have “knock on” effects for further research, particularly research on dietary changes during human evolution, and why the human dentition has evolved the way it has, he says.

“The regular tooth fractures in fossil humans may be caused by non-food items, such as grit or stone tools. However, regardless of the cause, these groups were subjected to substantial tooth wear and fractures. So, it raises questions to why our teeth reduced in size, especially compared to groups like Paranthropus.”

Dr Towle’s research will now focus on if our dentition evolved smaller due to other factors to allow other parts of the skull to expand, leading to evolution then favouring other tooth properties to protect it against wear and fracture, instead of increased tooth size.

“This is something we are investigating now, to see if tooth enamel may have evolved different characteristics among the great apes. Our research as a whole may also have implications for our understanding of oral health, since fossil human samples typically show immaculate dental health.

“Since extreme tooth wear and fractures were the norm, our ancestors likely evolved dental characteristics to not just cope with but actually utilise this dental tissue loss. For example, without substantial tooth wear our dentitions can face all sorts of issues, including impacted wisdom teeth, tooth crowding and even increased susceptibility to cavities.”

The research has been published in the Journal of Human Evolution [paper1, paper2] and the American Journal of Physical Anthropology respectively.

Source: University of Otago [July 23, 2021]

Support The Archaeology News Network with a small donation!


  1. Thanks a lot for this! 🙂
    This nicely fits our view of
    – australopiths feeding on wetland foods, e.g. chimps still feed sometimes on waterlilies, google "aquarboreal" or "ape human evolution made easy PPT verhaegen",
    – archaic Homo feeding regularly on littoral foods such as shellfish, google e.g. "coastal dispersal Pleistocene Homo PPT".



Related articles

Forearm artery reveals humans evolving from changes in natural selection

Humans haven't developed genetic mutations for telepathy or superpowers just yet, but a new study shows our species...

Chimpanzee study challenges distinctiveness of human cooperation

When given a choice between cooperating or competing, chimpanzees choose to cooperate five times more frequently Yerkes National...

Scientists debunk creationist arguments that dinosaurs and humans coexisted

An ancient cave drawing high on a rock formation in southeastern Utah has stirred a skirmish of sorts...

Scientists recover an ancient woman’s DNA from a 20,000-year-old pendant discovered in Denisova Cave

An international research team led by the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, has for...

Prehistoric men scarred, pierced, tattooed privates

Men in prehistoric Europe scarred, pierced and tattooed their penises, likely for ritualistic and social group reasons, according...

Risky food-finding strategy could be the key to human success

It’s a cold and rainy Sunday afternoon: would you rather be running after tasteless wild berries, or curled...

DNA adds twist to ancient story of Native American group

The ancient genomes of the Tsimshian indigenous people left tell-tale markers on the trail of their past, revealing...

Modelling study of ancient thumbs traces the history of hominin thumb dexterity

Despite long-standing ideas about the importance of thumb evolution in tool use and development, questions remain about exactly...