New sabre-tooth predator precedes cats by millions of years


Share post:

The fossil, housed in the San Diego Natural History Museum’s paleontology collection, offers a window into what the Earth was like during the Eocene Period, more than 40 million years ago. The specimen includes a lower jaw and well-preserved teeth, giving us new information about the behaviour and evolution of some of the first mammals to have an exclusively meat-based diet.

New sabre-tooth predator precedes cats by millions of years
Diegoalerus reconstruction [Credit: San Diego Natural History Museum]

“Today, the ability to eat an all-meat diet, also called hypercarnivory, isn’t uncommon. Tigers do it, polar bears can do it. If you have a house cat, you may even have a hypercarnivore at home. But 42 million years ago, mammals were only just figuring out how to survive on meat alone,” said Dr. Ashley Poust, postdoctoral researcher at the San Diego Natural History Museum (The Nat). “One big advance was to evolve specialized teeth for slicing flesh—which is something we see in this newly described specimen.”

This early meat-eating predator is part of a mysterious group of animals called Machaeroidines. Now completely extinct, they were not closely related to today’s living carnivores. “We know so little about Machaeroidines, so every new discovery greatly expands our picture of them,” said coauthor Dr. Shawn Zack of the University of Arizona College of Medicine. “This relatively complete, well-preserved Diegoaelurus fossil is especially useful because the teeth let us infer the diet and start to understand how Machaeroidines are related to each other,” said Zack.

Zack, Poust, and their third coauthor Hugh Wagner, also from The Nat, named the predator Diegoaelurus vanvalkenburghae. The name honors San Diego County where the specimen was found and scientist Blaire Van Valkenburgh, past president of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, whose foundational work on the evolution of carnivores influenced this research.

About the discovery

D. vanvalkenburghae was about the size of a bobcat, but with a downturned bony chin to protect its long upper sabre teeth. It would have been a powerful and relatively new kind of hunter.

New sabre-tooth predator precedes cats by millions of years
The Diegoaelurus jawbone fossil has been in The Nat’s collection since 1988. It was recovered from
a construction site in Oceanside by the museum’s PaleoServices team. When this carnivorous
animal was alive 42 million years ago, San Diego was covered in rainforests populated
by many small, unusual rodents, marsupials, primates and hooved mammals
[Credit: San Diego Natural History Museum]

“Nothing like this had existed in mammals before,” said Poust. “A few mammal ancestors had long fangs, but Diegoaelurus and its few relatives represent the first cat-like approach to an all-meat diet, with sabre-teeth in front and slicing scissor teeth called carnassials in the back. It’s a potent combination that several animal groups have independently evolved in the millions of years since.”

This animal and its relatives represent a sort of evolutionary experiment, a first stab at hypercarnivory—a lifestyle that is followed today by true cats. With only a handful of fossil specimens from Wyoming and Asia, the machaeroidines are so poorly understood that scientists weren’t even sure if there were multiple species living within the same time period. “This fossil finding shows that machaeroidines were more diverse than we thought,” says Zack. “We already knew there was a large form, Apataelurus, which lived in eastern Utah. Now we have this smaller form, and it lived at approximately the same time. It raises the possibility that there may more out there to find.”

In addition to this overlapping existence, Poust points out they may have coexisted with other sabre-toothed animals. “Diegoaleurus, though old, is the most recent of these machaeroidine predators. That puts it within striking distance of the time that the next cat-like animals arrived in North America, the nimravids or sabre-tooth false-cats,” he said. “Did these groups ever meet, or even compete for space and prey? We don’t know yet, but San Diego is proving to be a surprisingly important place for carnivore evolution.”

About the Santiago Formation

The fossil comes from San Diego County in southern California, at a location first discovered in the 1980s by a local 12-year-old boy. Since then, “Jeff’s Discovery Site” has become an important fossil bed within a larger group of rocks called the Santiago Formation. Fossils of an entire ecosystem have been discovered in these 42 million-year-old rocks, painting a picture of a very different San Diego than the one we know today. Though largely inaccessible, these important fossil beds are occasionally exposed by construction projects and road expansions, allowing scientists from The Nat to keep digging for evidence of California’s ancient, tropical past.

New sabre-tooth predator precedes cats by millions of years
Dr. Ashley Poust, a post-doctoral researcher at The Nat, has just described what is now the earliest
known cat-like predator in North America, west of the Rocky Mountains. The fossil in his hand
belonged to Diegoaelurus, a bobcat-sized carnivore that lived around 42 million years ago.
Diegoaelurus was much smaller than the commonly known Smilodon, or sabre-tooth cat, seen
in the background. Smilodon evolved roughly 40 million years after Diegoaelurus went extinct,
but both animals were saber-toothed, hyper-carnivorous predators, meaning their diets consisted
almost entirely of meat. Diegoaelurus and its few relatives, from Wyoming and China, were the
first predators to evolve sabre-teeth, though several other unrelated animals developed
this adaptation much later in time [Credit: San Diego Natural History Museum]

“Not only was San Diego further south due to tectonic plate movements, but the Eocene was a wetter, warmer world,” said Poust. “The Santiago Formation fossils show us a forested, wet California where tiny rhinos, early tapirs, and strange sheep-like, herbivorous oreodonts grazed under trees while unusual primates and marsupials clung to the canopy above. This richness of prey species would have been a smorgasbord for Diegoaelurus, allowing it to live the life of a specialized hunter before most other mammals.”

About the 3D model

The jaw of the newly named meat-eater is available to view in 3D for free on the San Diego Natural History Museum’s website.

To access this 3D model and view in your browser, go to

The findings are published in PeerJ.

Source: PeerJ [March 15, 2022]



Related articles

Sentinels of ocean acidification impacts survived Earth’s last mass extinction

Two groups of tiny, delicate marine organisms, sea butterflies and sea angels, were found to be surprisingly resilient--having...

Getting the dirt on B.C. fossils

As soon as she started digging into the legal battle faced by a doctor who found dinosaur tracks...

Ancient plankton help researchers predict near-future climate

The Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawai'i recently recorded the highest concentration of carbon dioxide, or CO2, levels in...

Paleontologists discover why the oceans are so diverse

A new study in the journal Science has given insight into why the world's oceans are full of...

Fossil teeth show how Jurassic reptiles adapted to changing seas

Marine predators that lived in deep waters during the Jurassic Period thrived as sea levels rose, while species...

Woolly rhino neck ribs provide clues about their decline and eventual extinction

Researchers from the Naturalis Biodiversity Center in Leiden examined woolly rhino and modern rhino neck vertebrae from several...

Mahogany tree family dates back to last hurrah of the dinosaurs

Mahogany is a commercially important wood, valued for its hardness and beauty. The United States is the world's...

Ancient ‘Texas Serengeti’ had elephant-like animals, rhinos, alligators and more

During the Great Depression, some unemployed Texans were put to work as fossil hunters. The workers retrieved tens...