Modelling study of ancient thumbs traces the history of hominin thumb dexterity


Share post:

Despite long-standing ideas about the importance of thumb evolution in tool use and development, questions remain about exactly when human-like manual dexterity and efficient thumb use arose–and which hominin species was the first to have this ability. Now, researchers who’ve analyzed the biomechanics and efficiency of the thumb across different fossil human species using virtual muscle modeling have new insight into when these abilities first arose and what they’ve meant for the development of more complex human culture. The findings, published in the journal Current Biology, suggest that a fundamental aspect of human thumb opposition first appeared approximately 2 million years ago and was not found in the earliest proposed stone tool makers.

Modelling study of ancient thumbs traces the history of hominin thumb dexterity
This image illustrates the difference between human and chimpanzee models of thumb muscles,
which the researchers used to study the evolution of thumb dexterity
[Credit: Professor Katerina Harvati, Dr. Alexandros Karakostis,
& Dr. Daniel Haeufle]

“Increased manual dexterity in the form of efficient thumb opposition was among the early defining characteristics of our lineage, providing a formidable adaptive advantage to our ancestors,” said Katerina Harvati of the Eberhard Karls University of Tubingen. “It is likely a crucial element underlying the development of complex culture over the last 2 million years, shaping our biocultural evolution.”

Earlier attempts to study thumb dexterity evolution had relied on comparisons between the skeletal anatomy of modern humans and earlier hominin species. The assumption was that similarities in skeletal remains to the human form could be taken as evidence of dexterity. In the new study, the team led by Harvati took a new and more comprehensive approach.

“Our methodology integrates cutting-edge virtual muscle modeling with three-dimensional analysis of bone shape and size,” first author and hand biomechanics expert Alexandros Karakostis, explains. “This process includes the precise 3D study of the areas of the bones where muscles attach in life. Importantly, we were able to validate the predictions of our models by confirming that the differences observed between living taxa–chimpanzees and modern humans–reflect those reported from past experimental studies.”

By applying this new approach to answer the question, the researchers showed that thumb efficiency and dexterity had increased to a significant extent in hominins that lived 2 million years ago in South Africa. At the same time, they found that the degree of this dexterity was consistently lower in the earliest proposed tool-making species, the Australopithecines. That includes the species Australopithecus sediba, which is also dated to approximately 2 million years ago. That’s notable because researchers had previously suggested that the human-like thumb proportions of A. sediba reflected tool-making capabilities.

This video shows the steps of the study’s novel and integrative analytical procedure 

[Credit: Harvati et al./Current Biology]

“One of the greatest surprises was to find that hominin hand fossils from the Swartkrans site in South Africa, which date to ca. 2 million years ago and are attributed to either early Homo or to the extinct hominin side branch Paranthropus robustus, could achieve a thumb-using dexterity similar to that of modern humans,” Karakostis said.

The new findings further show that later-arising species, belonging to our own genus Homo– including Neanderthals as well as early and recent Homo sapiens–share similarly high degrees of manual dexterity. Those findings applied also to the small-brained species Homo naledi, despite the fact that this species has not yet been found in association with stone tools.

“These consistently high dexterity levels in species of Homo are indicative of the great adaptive value of thumb opposition for human biocultural evolution,” Harvati says.

The researchers note that the most important implication of their new findings is that an early increase of thumb dexterity about 2 million years ago may have been a foundation for the gradual development of complex culture. They highlight that this timeframe includes important biocultural developments such as the appearance of the large-brained Homo erectus lineage and its dispersal out of Africa. Around the same time, humans gradually began to exploit animal resources and to rely more heavily on stone tool technologies.

The researchers now plan to look even more closely at specific groups, such as Neanderthals, so as to further elucidate the details of their manual dexterity and how they may have differed from that of modern humans. They’ll also more closely investigate the habitual manual activities of early hominins to further shed light on the behaviors that marked the transition to systematic tool production and use among our distant ancestors.

Source: Cell Press [January 28, 2021]

Support The Archaeology News Network with a small donation!



Related articles

Cultivating cooperation through kinship

While the capability for organisms to work together is by no means novel, humans possess an unparalleled capacity...

Neanderthals and Homo sapiens coexisted for less than 1000 years in the Cantabrian Region

Neanderthals and Homo sapiens could not have coexisted for more than a millennium in the Cantabrian Region, which...

GIANT study finds rare, but influential, genetic changes related to height

In the largest, deepest search to date, the international Genetic Investigation of Anthropometric Traits (GIANT) Consortium has uncovered...

Sharing leftover meat may have contributed to early dog domestication

Humans feeding leftover lean meat to wolves during harsh winters may have had a role in the early...

Surprising similarities in stone tools of early humans and monkeys

Researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology have discovered artefacts produced by old world monkeys in...

Researchers mapping genetic history of the Caribbean

In the island chain called the Lesser Antilles, stretching from the Virgin Islands south to Trinidad and Tobago,...

Differences in genes’ geographic origin influence mitochondrial function

Differences in the geographic origin of genes may affect the function of human mitochondria--energy-generating organelles inside of cells--according...

Ecuadorean villagers may hold secret to longevity

People living in remote villages in Ecuador have a mutation that some biologists say may throw light on...