Large human brain evolved as a result of ‘sizing each other up’

Date:

Share post:

A team led by computer scientists at Cardiff University suggest that the challenge of judging a person’s relative standing and deciding whether or not to cooperate with them has promoted the rapid expansion of human brain size over the last 2 million years.

Large human brain evolved as a result of 'sizing each other up'
Humans have evolved a disproportionately large brain as a result of sizing each other up in large cooperative 
social groups, researchers have proposed [Credit: Matt Cardy/Getty Images]

In a study published in Scientific Reports, the team, which also includes leading evolutionary psychologist Professor Robin Dunbar from the University of Oxford, specifically found that evolution favors those who prefer to help out others who are at least as successful as themselves.

Lead author of the study Professor Roger Whitaker, from Cardiff University’s School of Computer Science and Informatics, said: “Our results suggest that the evolution of cooperation, which is key to a prosperous society, is intrinsically linked to the idea of social comparison — constantly sizing each up and making decisions as to whether we want to help them or not.

“We’ve shown that over time, evolution favors strategies to help those who are at least as successful as themselves.”

In their study, the team used computer modelling to run hundreds of thousands of simulations, or ‘donation games’, to unravel the complexities of decision-making strategies for simplified humans and to establish why certain types of behaviour among individuals begins to strengthen over time.

In each round of the donation game, two simulated players were randomly selected from the population. The first player then made a decision on whether or not they wanted to donate to the other player, based on how they judged their reputation. If the player chose to donate, they incurred a cost and the receiver was given a benefit. Each player’s reputation was then updated in light of their action, and another game was initiated.

Compared to other species, including our closest relatives, chimpanzees, the brain takes up much more body weight in human beings. Humans also have the largest cerebral cortex of all mammals, relative to the size of their brains. This area houses the cerebral hemispheres, which are responsible for higher functions like memory, communication and thinking.

The research team propose that making relative judgements through helping others has been influential for human survival, and that the complexity of constantly assessing individuals has been a sufficiently difficult task to promote the expansion of the brain over many generations of human reproduction.

Professor Robin Dunbar, who previously proposed the social brain hypothesis, said: “According to the social brain hypothesis, the disproportionately large brain size in humans exists as a consequence of humans evolving in large and complex social groups.

“Our new research reinforces this hypothesis and offers an insight into the way cooperation and reward may have been instrumental in driving brain evolution, suggesting that the challenge of assessing others could have contributed to the large brain size in humans.”

According to the team, the research could also have future implications in engineering, specifically where intelligent and autonomous machines need to decide how generous they should be towards each other during one-off interactions.

“The models we use can be executed as short algorithms called heuristics, allowing devices to make quick decisions about their cooperative behaviour,” Professor Whitaker said.

“New autonomous technologies, such as distributed wireless networks or driverless cars, will need to self-manage their behaviour but at the same time cooperate with others in their environment.”

Source: Cardiff University [August 15, 2016]

1 COMMENT

  1. Why always try to find far-fetched just-so "explanations", while we can simply use the comparative evidence: (semi)aquatic mammals typically have much larger brains than equally large terrestrial relatives. Human ancestors were no exception: Pleistocene Homo dispersed intercontinentally along African & Eurasian coasts & rivers, even reaching islands far overseas such as Flores, Sulawesi, Crete or Cyprus. They collected waterside & shallow-aquatic foods, incl. shellfish, which are richest in brain-specific nutrients (DHA).

ADVERTISEMENT

spot_img

Related articles

Iraq national museum long way from public opening

In Iraq's national museum, home to some of the world's most precious artifacts of ancient Mesopotamia, a caption...

Cassini mission provides insight into Saturn

Scientists have found the first direct evidence for explosive releases of energy in Saturn's magnetic bubble using data...

More on 19th century Parthenon Marble shipwreck explored

The Mentor was sailing from Piraeus to the coast of England via Malta, carrying some 17 cases of...

Clocking the rotation rate of a supermassive black hole

A recent observational campaign involving more than two dozen optical telescopes and NASA's space based SWIFT X-ray telescope...

New synthesis method imitates the way molecules were formed at the dawn of life on Earth

Researchers from the Institute for Advanced Chemistry of Catalonia (IQAC-CSIC), with support from the Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Service...

Researchers find evidence of original 1620 Plymouth settlement

Three hundred and ninety-five years after Pilgrims celebrated the first Thanksgiving in Plymouth, Massachusetts, researchers from UMass Boston's...

Antibiotic contamination a threat to Humans and the Environment

More than 10,000 tonnes of antibiotics are consumed in Europe each year, and 30-60% pass through animals and...

One secret of ancient amber revealed

The warm beauty of amber was captivating and mysterious enough to inspire myths in ancient times, and even...