Large heads, narrow pelvises and difficult childbirth in humans

Date:

Share post:

The size of the neonatal skull is large relative to the dimensions of the birth canal in the female pelvis. This is the reason why childbirth is slower and more difficult in humans than in most other primates. Scientists from the Universities of Oslo and Vienna, identified adaptations in the morphology of the human body, which were unknown so far.

Large heads, narrow pelvises and difficult childbirth in humans
The skull of a newborn must fit through the female pelvis at birth — it has to be 
as big as the diameter of the birth canal [Credit: Magdalena Fischer]

Upright walking and difficult birth

In hominids, upright walking evolved 4-5 million years ago. The human pelvis was affected by these changes and evolved accordingly to better serve the new pattern of movement. Later, after bipedal movement had long become obligatory, brains evolved to increasingly larger volumes. With that change, the head size of neonates also increased. The growing heads, however, had to be delivered through pelvises that were earlier adapted to upright walking. This is the reason for the lack of space in the modern human birth canal during childbirth, which we have to live with today. The evolution of these patterns remains to have severe consequences. Women in developing countries, who do not have access to modern medical care or cesarean sections during birth, still suffer from high mortality due to childbirth.

Analysis of 3D data

Barbara Fischer, an evolutionary biologist at the Universities of Oslo and Vienna, had the idea to study the consequences of this persistent strong selection pressure due to childbirth on human morphology. Together with Philipp Mitteroecker, an anthropologist at the University of Vienna, she analyzed 3D data of the human pelvis to study these questions. The data that they used in their analysis had originally been collected for a very different purpose.

Large heads, narrow pelvises and difficult childbirth in humans
With
the use of 3D data, the authors identified a relationship between the
shape

 of the pelvis, the body size and head circumference [Credit: PNAS]

“The motivation for the US-American researchers who collected these pelvis data in the 1980s was an industrial one. They wanted to improve the design of crash test devices and car seats to increase vehicle safety,” explains Fischer. A large number of human pelvises were measured in detail for this reason.

With these data, Fischer and Mitteroecker discovered a complex association between the shape of the pelvis, body height and head size, within the human body. This association helps to ease the obstetric dilemma. Their results show that the dimensions of head and height do not vary independently, but instead they are linked to pelvis shape.

Head and stature

The size of the human head is to a large extent genetically determined. This is why women with large heads tend to give birth to neonates with large heads. “We found out that women with large heads, compared to women with small heads, possess a birth canal that is shaped in a way that neonates with large heads can pass it easier,” explains Barbara Fischer: The sacrum is shorter in these women and it leaves more space in the outlet of the birth canal, which is beneficial for birth.

It is well known from the gynecological literature that short women, compared to taller women, on average have harder births and carry a higher risk that the fetus will not fit through the birth canal at birth. Fischer and Mitteroecker show in their study that shorter women possess a rounder birth canal, which is likely an adaptation to the stronger selection pressure at birth in these women. Despite the identified patterns, the authors clarify that the individual risk for a difficult birth depends on various environmental influences along with genetic factors.

The results of this new study appeared in the current edition of Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Source: University of Vienna [April 23, 2015]

1 COMMENT

  1. Interesting paper in PNAS, but you say "in hominids, upright walking evolved 4-5 Ma. The human pelvis was affected by these changes and evolved accordingly to better serve the new pattern of movement. Later, after bipedal movement had long become obligatory, brains evolved to increasingly larger volumes." This simplistic idea has been repeated so often, not only in popular but also in "scientific" papers on human evolution, that is became a "fact", but the reality is a lot more complex: the different elements of human locomotion did not evolve at once, but arose mosaic-like: most early hominoids (e.g. Morotopithecus ~20 Ma) were already vertical climbers, gibbons & humans (still?) have vertical spines most of the time, most Mio-Pliocene hominoids incl.australopiths were generally "upright", not for walking or running on terra firma, but for climbing vertically in the branches above the forest swamps (where their fossils lay) or for wading on 2 legs like lowland gorillas still do in the forest bais (collecting floating & waterside vegetation, e.g frogbit, sedges): Lucy had curved phalanges, an adaptation for branch-hanging. The evolution of wading/walking on 2 legs ("bipedality"), of an upright posture with vertical lumbar spine (“orthogrady”), of "aligned" build (head-spine-legs in 1 line), of very long & straight legs etc. – which are 4 different things – is more (bio)logical but also more complex than most traditional paleo-anthropologists think. Fossil, paleo-environmental, archeological, isotopic & comparative data independently show that Pleistocene human ancestors did not run over the open plains (google econiche Homo), e.g. the malacological data show that virtually all archaic Homo fossils and tools were associated with shallow water habitats & edible shellfish (Munro 2010 “Molluscs as ecological indicators in palaeoanthropoloigcal contexts” PhD thesis Canberra), google researchGate marc verhaegen

ADVERTISEMENT

spot_img

Related articles

Gravitational telescope creates space invader mirage

The NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope is one of the most powerful available to astronomers, but sometimes it too...

A grassy trend in Human ancestors’ diets

Most apes eat leaves and fruits from trees and shrubs. New studies spearheaded by the University of Utah...

Ancient graves unearthed in Strathmore

A series of burial mounds have been excavated — thought to represent an ancient barrow cemetery — at...

Rover Opportunity wrapping up study of Martian valley

"Marathon Valley," slicing through a large crater's rim on Mars, has provided fruitful research targets for NASA's Opportunity...

Storms expose archaeology on Omey island

Destruction wreaked along Connacht’s coastline in the recent storms has exposed archaeology dating back to the Neolithic period...

New species from the Pliocene of Tibet reveals origin of Ice Age mountain sheep

Modern wild sheep, Ovis, is widespread in the mountain ranges of the Caucasus through Himalaya, Tibetan Plateau, Tianshan-Altai,...

26th Dynasty ushabti figure returning to Egypt

Next week Egypt is to recover a 26th Dynasty ushabti torso that was reported missing from the Egyptian...

Plea to save Iranian Elamite Bas-Relief

An archaeologist has asked Iran's Cultural Heritage, Tourism and Handicrafts Organization (CHTHO) to save the Elamite rock bas-relief...