Isotopic analyses link the lives of Late Neolithic individuals to burial location in Spain


Share post:

An isotopic analysis of megalithic graves and caves in Spain may suggest the existence of a degree of differentiation in the lifeways of people buried in these different funerary sites, according to a study published in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Teresa Fernández-Crespo and Rick Schulting from the University of the Basque Country, Spain, and the University of Oxford, UK.

Isotopic analyses link the lives of Late Neolithic individuals to burial location in Spain
A megalithic graves analysed (Chabola de la Hechicera), and in the background, the Cantabria mountain range, 
where the caves included in the study are located [Credit: Teresa Fernández-Crespo/UPV/EHU]

Previous research on the burial practices of the Western European Neolithic has revealed variation in burial location and treatment, but their significance is difficult to interpret. To further investigate the meaning behind different burial practices within the same location and period, the authors of the present study analyzed the bone collagen carbon and nitrogen isotope measurements of 166 individuals from a series of broadly contemporary Late Neolithic (3500 to 2900 cal BC) mortuary monuments and caves, closely situated together in north-central Spain.

The researchers’ isotopic analysis of both megalithic graves and caves suggests a similar C3 plant-based human diet, mostly consisting of wheat and barley, as well as a substantial amount of protein from cattle and sheep. However, the study surprisingly reveals significant carbon isotope differences between people interred in both funerary site-types. These differences seem to be correlated with elevation, temperature, and precipitation, implying that land use was partitioned on a surprisingly local scale.

The authors propose two possible explanations. The first is that this division of land could indicate different socioeconomic classes within the same community, with the lower classes being interred in caves with restricted access to agricultural resources, while the individuals of higher status in the community were buried in monumental graves whose construction would involve a considerable investment of labor. Alternatively, they also consider the possibility that this partitioning of the landscape may involve different populations performing different funerary practices and following distinct subsistence economies in some respect.

Further research on tooth dentine and enamel will explore the age at which the isotopic differences first appeared and investigate different patterns of mobility and landscape-use in the study area. This study offers new insights into different mortuary practices and specifically how they related to lifeways, particularly dietary and subsistence practices, and implications for the emergence of socioeconomic inequality in the Western European Neolithic.

“Using carbon and nitrogen stable isotope analysis of human and animal remains, our study has identified meaningful differences between those buried in caves and megalithic graves in the Late Neolithic of north-central Spain,” says Teresa Fernández-Crespo. “This implies that, despite living in close proximity, these communities had distinct lifeways involving a partitioning of the landscape.”

Source: Public Library of Science [September 27, 2017]



Related articles

Million-year-old tools found in India

Archaeologists have discovered India’s oldest stone-age tools, up to 1.5 million years old, at a prehistoric site near...

One of the longest pterosaur trails found in Portugal

One of the longest and rarest pterosaur trails has been found along a beach in Lourinhã, about 70...

An unprecedented threat to Peru’s cloud forests

Peru's cloud forests are some of the most biologically diverse ecosystems in the world. A profusion of tree...

Tracking down the first chefs

Archaeological sites speak about the everyday lives of people in other times. Yet knowing how to interpret this...

Fossils from the ‘Great Dying’

A recently discovered fossil trove in south-west China has thrown new light on an ecosystem recovery after the...

Jellyfish on the rise in world’s coastal ecosytems

Jellyfish are increasing in the majority of the world's coastal ecosystems, according to the first global study of...

What makes rainforests unique? History, not ecology

History and geology, not current ecology, are likely what has made tropical forests so variable from site to...

Low Mississippi River exposes shipwreck

Calling all available archaeologists. Low water on the Mississippi River has revealed a mystery on the banks near...