Historical wildlife trends reliable for predicting species at risk


Share post:

Some of the methods used to predict at risk species are trend-based — an indicator of what happens gradually over time — while others are trait based, which uses signs of climate change in the current environment. Mix these methods together, however, and you get an unreliable set of results, scientist have found.

Historical wildlife trends reliable for predicting species at risk
Adonis Blue Butterfly [Credit: University of York]

The researchers are calling for guidelines produced by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List, the world’s main authority on species that are at risk of extinction, to be updated to include cautionary messages on some methodologies of climate change risk assessment.

Christopher Wheatley, PhD student at the University’s Department of Biology, said: “We looked at 12 methods of assessing the potential risk of climate change on British birds and butterflies. These methods tend to be used interchangeably to come to an agreement on how much risk is posed by climate change.”

Researchers tested the 12 methods by running the assessment as though the data was being collected in the 1970s. They then looked at whether the results matched the reality of the British bird and butterfly population today.

Historical wildlife trends reliable for predicting species at risk
Woodlark [Credit: University of York]

Professor Chris Thomas, also at the University’s Department of Biology, said: “We found that methods relying on historical climate change trends from the 1970s to today identified high risk species that have consistently declining populations over time.

“Those methods that relied on species trait information showed very little pattern, and therefore it was difficult to use this data to explain the populations that we see today.”

In some cases, at risk populations live in environments that are remote and as a result it is expensive to collect data over a sustained period of time. In these circumstances historical data will be missing and environmentalists have no choice but to fall back on methods that look at traits not trends.

Historical wildlife trends reliable for predicting species at risk
Scotch Argus Butterfly [Credit: University of York]

Richard Bradbury, from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), said: “Although we appreciate historical data is not always available, mixing these methods to come to firm conclusions about a species’ chance of survival, provides a false picture of what is really happening and we would advise caution when looking at this information.

“We also hope that this research will highlight the importance of long term monitoring of environments in accurately assessing species extinction risk.”

The team is now investigating the risk from climate change to bird and butterfly populations across Europe and how existing assessments may have underestimated their chances of survival against a changing climate.

The research is published in the journal Global Change Biology.

Source: University of York [August 02, 2017]



Related articles

Greek islands were inhabited 170,000 years ago

Neanderthals and other extinct human lineages might have been ancient mariners, venturing to the Mediterranean islands thousands of...

Astronomers welcome unexpected asteroid findings

What seemed to be rock-solid assumptions about the nature of small asteroids may end in collections of rubble...

‘Magnificent’ cave discovered in Crete

Workers placing new biological treatment pipes in the village Fodele of the Municipality of Malevizio, Crete, came across...

Iberian lynx not doomed by its genetics

The low genetic diversity of the Iberian lynx – the most endangered carnivore in Europe – may not...

A lost frog in the lost world?

Ecotourism and Conservation -- Can it work? In the context of a study in the forests of Central...

Ancient Herculaneum gains ground

Herculaneum, Pompeii’s “little sister”, will soon be given some much needed breathing space thanks to funds from the...

Most ancient supernovas are discovered

Supernovas -- stars in the process of exploding -- open a window onto the history of the elements...

Neanderthal viruses found in modern Humans

Ancient viruses from Neanderthals have been found in modern human DNA by researchers at Oxford University and Plymouth...