Biodiversity loss: Political actions are required, not additional scientific knowledge


Share post:

Over 15 years, almost 13,000 scientific papers have been published in leading conservation science journals. Yet biodiversity remains threatened at a global scale. Two CNRS researchers have focused on this worrisome paradox by taking a deeper look at this large volume of literature. One of the major problems is that decisions are usually more favorable to human activities than to nature protection. Their study appears in Trends in Ecology and Evolution.

Biodiversity loss: Political actions are required, not additional scientific knowledge
The population of green turtles (Chelonia mydas) illustrates an impressive successful conservation measure. After concrete
 protection and banning their trade that had decimated their population, the average number of green turtle clutches
deposited annually at Ascension Island has increased sixfold between 1977 and 2013. (Photograph taken on Moorea)
[Credit: Thomas Vignaud/Te Mana O Te Moana/Centre for Island Research and Environmental Observatory
(Perpignan)/CNRS Photo Library]

The sixth mass extinction is accelerating, but conservation scientists, critics claim, offer no solutions. Some argue that conservation findings are so pessimistic that their warnings are actually counterproductive. But is this really the case? Two CNRS researchers have addressed this question. They examined the 12,971 research articles published during the last 15 years in the main scientific journals dedicated to conservation.

Excluding articles dealing with discussions in the discipline, they proposed the first extensive empirical assessment of the scientific background and output of conservation science in describing the current status of biodiversity, the threats, and the solutions accumulated by scientists.

Their initial conclusion is indisputable: the remaining threats to biodiversity today were already identified nearly 40 years ago, when they were quoted the “evil quartet.” They are (i) habitat destruction (ii) overexploitation of resources, i.e., overhunting or overfishing for example; (iii) introduction of invasive species; and (iv) co-extinctions that may be triggered by these factors. To these four well-established threats, researchers add the concern of climate change, which further destabilizes natural environments. And it is not “exotic” biodiversity alone that is endangeredā€”most research has focused on European ecosystems, showing that populations of common species and habitats are also suffering. This is, for example, the case for birds in the French countryside.

But fortunately, conservation research also reports good news like the comeback of the wolf in Europe and clear improvements resulting from the application of conservation measures. Hence, they conclude that conservation science is neither pessimistic nor optimisticā€”just realistic. According to the researchers, a lot of sustainable and human-friendly solutions are already available. The major obstacle is the demand for concessions even more favorable to resource exploitation rather than to nature protection, despite timid scientific recommendations.

Source: CNRS [September 12, 2018]



Related articles

Climate change has silver lining for grizzlies

Global warming and forest disturbances may have a silver lining for threatened species of grizzly bears in Alberta,...

Arctic change has widespread impacts

As the Arctic warms faster than the rest of the globe, permafrost, land ice and sea ice are...

DNA analysis reveals cryptic underwater ecosystem engineers

They look like smears of pink bubblegum on the rocks off British Columbia's coast, indistinguishable from one another. Coralline...

Swift parrots bred on predator-free islands at risk of extinction

New research from The Australian National University (ANU) has found genetic evidence that critically endangered swift parrots, which...

Study shows gravitational forces deep within Earth have great impact on landscape evolution

Stony Brook University is leading a research project that focuses on the interplay between the evolution of the...

Dismay as huge chunk of Greenland’s ice cap breaks off

An enormous chunk of Greenland's ice cap has broken off in the far northeastern Arctic, a development that...

New study identifies thermometer for the past global ocean

There's a new way to measure the average temperature of the ocean thanks to researchers at Scripps Institution...

Shrinking of Greenland’s glaciers began accelerating in 2000, research finds

Satellite data has given scientists clues about how, when and why Greenland's glaciers are shrinking - and shows...