Archaeologist claims vallum was abandoned Roman road


Share post:

A CONTROVERSIAL archaeologist has turned received wisdom on its head to explain the purpose of the 112km vallum running the length of Hadrian’s Wall. The trench – 6m wide and up to 3m deep – is unique in Roman construction and has long been the source of debate.

Controversial: Geoff Carter claims the vallum which ruins alongside Hadrian’s Wall was the contruction trench for a road. Located a few metres to the south of Hadrian’s finest achievement, the majority verdict is that it was a barrier providing additional protection for the Wall itself.

Another suggestion is that it helped contain livestock, delineating grazing land at the foot of the wall for the herds kept by the Roman forts.

However, Tynedale-based structural archaeologist Geoff Carter, the man who previously floated the theory the Roman Wall was first constructed in timber, believes differently.

It is, in fact, the construction trench for a road that was abandoned when the scale of the project became unwieldy, he claims.

“The vallum is unique, always a problem to archaeology, where insights so often come from comparing things,” he said.

“However, there is a simple and less ambiguous explanation for the creation of the vallum; it is a construction trench for a road that was never completed.

“The quality of a road, or other civil engineering project, was a reflection of the person who initiated and sponsored it.

“A Roman politician’s prestige and standing was, in part, a reflection of the nature and quality of the engineering ‘good works’ that bore his name.

“In this context, a plan to construct a high quality properly bedded, road along Hadrian’s new frontier is not surprising.”

When it was constructed, the vallum ran in an unbroken line the length of the Wall, so it would have provided a link between each of the forts along the way.

It had often been observed that its construction mirrored that of a Roman road, in that it had long straight stretches linked by gentle bends, and it avoided soft ground and steep gradients.

In the central section, where the Wall ran along the crags of the Whin Sill, the vallum stayed down in the valley.

And the only places where it was interrupted was where the causeways would have been that led into the forts and some of the milecastles.

“Most authors have sought to explain the vallum as a physical boundary that defines some form of military zone, restricting access to or from the Wall,” said Geoff.

“Like the Wall itself, the vallum would have represented a formidable obstacle to north-south movement.

“But the ambiguity of this explanation arises from the observation that a simple bank and ditch could have served this function more efficiently, and might be considered standard practice in the circumstances.”

He was sure the trench had been dug to house a road bed for a central carriageway, and the two parallel lines of spoil heaps – still in evidence today – set back on either side to allow room for the lanes used by riders and pedestrians.

However, the project to build a road linking the forts between the bridgehead at Newcastle and the west coast still had a long way to go.

A huge workforce would have had to be brought in for the more highly skilled construction phase, and around three million tons of aggregate and a mortared stone capping were required to do the job.

Geoff said: “If we accept the vallum was a military road, abandoned during construction, then it adds further weight to the arguments that the building of Hadrian’s Wall was interrupted, and then scaled down when work was resumed.

“The form, layout and route of the vallum all indicate that this earthwork was a road, albeit an unfinished one. This is the only rational engineering explanation.”

Source: Hexham Courant [January 04, 2011]



Related articles

MSU paleontologists excavate dinosaur clutches in China

Montana State University paleontologists recently excavated four clutches of dinosaur eggs in China and found at least four...

Antikythera seabed the subject of another underwater search

It was just before Easter in 1900 when two boats belonging to sponge divers from Symi took refuge...

Jain basadi at Talakad to be excavated

The ancient site of Talakad continues to beckon archaeologists and explorers hoping to uncover the world buried in...

New Zealand’s Takahē have African cousins

New research from Massey University suggests that New Zealand's Takahē have African cousins and that our Pūkeko are...

Bighorn sheep went extinct on desert island in Gulf of California

Using ancient DNA analysis and other techniques, a research team led by conservation biologists at the University of...

1.2-million-year-old fish fossil discovered in Istanbul

A 1.2-million-year-old fish fossil was discovered in a piece of marble in İstanbul's Esenler district last week. This fossilized...

Radical theory explains the origin, evolution and nature of life

The earth is alive, asserts a revolutionary scientific theory of life emerging from Case Western Reserve University School...

2,500 year old mausoleum in southern Turkey defaced

A 2,500-year-old mausoleum in the southern Turkish province of Antalya has become the victim of vandalism. AA Photo Considered one...